By: Annet Preethi Furtado
April 1 2024
Old, unrelated photos falsely linked to Opposition bloc's Ramlila Maidan rally in Delhi
Share Article:
Screenshot of X posts with captions these pictures show the crowd of people in the 'Save Democracy Rally' organized by 'India' alliance at Ramlila Maidan in Delhi. (Source: X/Screenshot/Modified by Logically Facts)
Fact-Check
The Verdict False
Unrelated photos from an African race event and a political rally in Kolkata were shared as 'pro-CM Kejriwal supporters' at Opposition's Delhi rally.
Claim ID 5fa70cca
With the 2024 Lok Sabha elections scheduled to take place in multiple phases from April 19 to June 1, 2024, leaders of the Opposition coalition, the Indian National Developmental Inclusive Alliance (INDIA), organized a "Loktantra Bachao" rally at New Delhi's Ramlila Maidan on March 31, 2024. This rally follows the recent arrest of Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) in connection with an alleged liquor excise policy scam.
What's the claim?
Against this backdrop, numerous aerial images have emerged, purportedly depicting massive crowds rallying in support of Kejriwal in Delhi at the 'Loktantra Bachao Rally' organized by the Opposition bloc.
One such image, portraying a sizable gathering of individuals clad in yellow attire, has been circulated as evidence of Kejriwal's support base. The accompanying Hindi captions, upon translation, assert: "The streets of Delhi are brimming with Kejriwal supporters," accompanied by the hashtag #IndiaWithKejriwal.
At the time of writing, one such post featuring the viral image had accumulated over 424,000 views. Archived versions of this post and others like it can be found here, here, and here.
Screenshot of X posts. (Source: X/Screenshot/ Modified by Logically Facts)
Another such aerial image depicting a sizable crowd has gained viral attention, purporting to be a recent snapshot from the rally at Delhi's Ramlila Maidan. Captions accompanying this image claim, "Scenes from today at the Ramlila Maidan Alliance Rally. Modi toh giyo #INDIAAlliance."
Screenshot of X posts. (Source: X/Screenshot/ Modified by Logically Facts)
One such post sharing the viral image had garnered 407,000 views at the time of writing. Archived and similar versions of the post can be viewed here, and here.
However, the first picture can be traced back to an African event. Similarly, another image purported to be from the recent rally in Delhi is an old picture from West Bengal dating back to 2019.
What are the facts?
Image 1
After conducting a reverse image search of the first image, it was discovered that it originated from the official account of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Ethiopia, posted on January 23, 2022. The post's caption indicated that the image portrays Africa's largest running competition, the 'Great Ethiopian Run,' an annual road running event in Ethiopia.
Furthermore, we discovered a similar image uploaded to the United Nations Millennium Development Goals (MDG) Achievement Funds website. The accompanying description stated, "Haile Gebreselassie kicks off the Great Ethiopian Run under the slogan 'We Can End Poverty by 2015.'" This image, captured from a different angle, displayed a signboard featuring the words "Abyssinia Springs."
Even in May 2022, this exact image resurfaced, falsely representing a gathering of Chennai Super Kings fans at the 2023 IPL final, alongside other unrelated images. In a fact-check, Logically Facts uncovered that images from events held in different years in Spain, Africa, and Thailand were being misrepresented as visuals of CSK fans at the IPL final.
Image 2
A reverse image search led us to a 2019 news article by People's Democracy, an English weekly newspaper of the Communist Party of India, featuring the viral image. The article reported that thousands of Left Party workers attended a Left Front-led rally held at Kolkata's Brigade Parade ground.
Moreover, a post by the CPI(M) West Bengal unit on X, dated June 10, 2020, shared the same image with the caption 'A bird's eye view of last year's Brigade Rally at Kolkata,' confirming its origin from the 2019 meeting.
This picture was also featured on the India Content website with the caption 'Kolkata: Workers of leftist parties participate in a Left Front rally at the Brigade Parade ground in Kolkata on February 3, 2019,' crediting wire agency IANS for the photo. The same photograph was also discovered on Alamy's stock photo website, and a similar description accompanied it.
Rally at Kolkata's Brigade Parade in 2019
Reports published on websites like Peoples Dispatch, Peoples Democracy, and Social News in February 2019 disclosed that thousands of Left party workers took part in the rally held at Kolkata's Brigade Parade ground on February 3, 2019. These reports highlighted that the rally was staged in opposition to the BJP-led government at the Centre and the TMC-led government in the state.
It was reported that during this rally, held in anticipation of the 2019 Lok Sabha elections in India, a resolution was adopted calling for the removal of the BJP and TMC governments from the state.
The verdict
Old and unrelated images from the 2022 Great Ethiopian Run in Africa and a rally held at Kolkata's Brigade Parade ground on February 3, 2019, have been circulated with the false claim that they depict scenes from the 2024 ‘Loktantra Bachao’ rally, which purportedly featured Kejriwal supporters in Delhi. As a result, we have marked the claim as false.